$2 vs $3 · ATT vs ATT
South Africa's all-time top scorer. Porto Champions League winner 2004 under Mourinho. Blackburn Rovers Premier League striker.
Signature: South Africa's all-time top scorer
$2 take: Bargain — gives you $8 for the rest. Perfect for filling a balanced squad.
More on Benni McCarthy →Africa's all-time top scorer (Cameroon level). Treble winner with Barcelona (2009) AND Inter (2010) — only player ever in two consecutive trebles.
Signature: Back-to-back trebles
$3 take: Sweet spot. Lets you afford a $5 GOAT or two $3 anchors.
More on Samuel Eto'o →Benni McCarthy is the cheaper pick at $2, leaving you $8 for the rest of your squad.
Better value depends on the rest of your $10 squad. Both can fit in a $10 lineup — but only one at a time if combined cost exceeds your budget ($5/10 = ✅ pair them).
Benni McCarthy costs $2, Samuel Eto'o costs $3. Benni McCarthy is cheaper.
Yes — combined cost is $5/10, leaving $5 for other positions.
Benni McCarthy is in the GOAT tier.